Skip to content

10 Unexpected Items That Sell Like Hotcakes at Garage Sales

When planning a garage sale, most people focus on getting rid of old clothes, books, and household items. However, some unexpected treasures in your home might be the real moneymakers. In this post, we'll explore ten surprising items that tend to fly off the shelves at garage sales, potentially putting more cash in your pocket.

  1. Vintage board games
  2. Old tools
  3. Vintage kitchenware
  4. Vinyl records
  5. Vintage cameras
  6. Retro video games and consoles
  7. Vintage clothing and accessories
  8. Antique door knobs and hardware
  9. Vintage magazines and advertisements
  10. Outdated technology

1. Vintage Board Games

While you might think that old board games are just taking up space, many collectors are eager to get their hands on vintage editions. Games from the 1960s, 70s, and 80s, especially if they're in good condition with all pieces intact, can fetch a pretty penny. Popular titles like original Monopoly sets, Classic Clue, or first-edition Trivial Pursuit are particularly sought after.

2. Old Tools

You might be surprised to learn that those rusty old tools in your garage could be worth something. Many DIY enthusiasts and collectors are always on the lookout for vintage tools, particularly those made by well-known brands like Stanley or Craftsman. Even if they're not in perfect condition, these tools often sell quickly as buyers see potential in restoring them.

3. Vintage Kitchenware

Retro kitchen items are experiencing a resurgence in popularity. Pyrex dishes with vintage patterns, old cast iron skillets, and mid-century modern kitchen gadgets are highly desirable. Even seemingly mundane items like vintage Tupperware or old cookie jars can attract buyers looking to add a touch of nostalgia to their kitchens.

4. Vinyl Records

In the age of digital music, you might think those old vinyl records are worthless. Think again! Vinyl has made a huge comeback, and collectors are always on the hunt for rare or classic albums. Even if the records aren't in mint condition, music enthusiasts might snap them up for the artwork or to complete their collections.

Love vinyl records but don't have a record player? We recommend this turntable.

5. Vintage Cameras

Old film cameras, especially those from well-known brands like Kodak, Polaroid, or Leica, can be surprisingly valuable. Many photography enthusiasts enjoy collecting and using vintage cameras, while others appreciate them as decorative items. Even if the camera doesn't work, it might still sell quickly to someone looking for a unique piece of decor.

6. Retro Video Games and Consoles

If you've held onto old video game systems like the original Nintendo, Sega Genesis, or early PlayStation models, you might be sitting on a goldmine. Retro gaming has become increasingly popular, with collectors willing to pay top dollar for classic games and consoles, especially if they're in good working condition with original packaging.

7. Vintage Clothing and Accessories

While you might think your old clothes are outdated, vintage fashion is always in style. Items from specific decades, particularly the 60s, 70s, and 80s, are highly sought after. This includes not just clothing, but also accessories like sunglasses, handbags, and jewelry. Even old band t-shirts or concert merchandise can fetch a good price from the right buyer.

8. Antique Door Knobs and Hardware

Believe it or not, old door knobs, hinges, and other hardware items can be hot sellers at garage sales. Many people renovating older homes are looking for period-appropriate fixtures, and original pieces are often preferred over reproductions. If you have any ornate or unusual hardware lying around, it might be worth more than you think.

Need to clean the door knobs and hardware to get top dollar? The Pink Stuff works great!

9. Vintage Magazines and Advertisements

Old magazines, especially those featuring iconic cover art or significant historical events, can be valuable to collectors. Similarly, vintage advertisements, particularly those for well-known brands or featuring popular cultural icons, are often in demand. These items offer a glimpse into the past and can be used for everything from research to home decor.

10. Outdated Technology

While it might seem counterintuitive, some outdated technology items can be surprisingly popular at garage sales. Old iPods, early model smartphones, or even floppy disks can attract buyers. Some people collect these items out of nostalgia, while others might use them for art projects or as props. Even if the technology is no longer functional, there might be someone interested in giving it a new life.

10 UNEXPECTED ITEMS THAT SELLHave a great sale!

When preparing for your next garage sale, don't overlook these unexpected items. What you consider junk might be someone else's treasure. Take some time to research the potential value of items you're unsure about – you might be surprised at what you find.

Remember, pricing these items can be tricky. While you want to make a profit, garage sale shoppers are often looking for bargains. Consider pricing items slightly below their potential resale value to encourage quick sales while still making a good return.

Lastly, presentation is key. Clean and organize your items, and consider grouping similar things together. For valuable or collector's items, you might want to do a bit of research and include information cards explaining their significance or history.

With these tips in mind and an eye out for these unexpected hot sellers, you're well on your way to hosting a successful and profitable garage sale. Happy selling!